A good putter can transform your game. Whether it’s draining clutch par saves or lagging those long ones close, finding the right flat stick is a must for all golfers. Pre-owned putters are a fantastic way to access premium models without the premium price, giving you the chance to find the perfect balance of forgiveness, feel, and alignment help.
At Golfclubs4cash, we’ve compiled a list of the best putters released from 2015 onward. Ranked on forgiveness, alignment, feel, and distance control, here are the top 10.
Our Top 10 picks For The Best Putters You Can Buy Pre-Owned In 2025
Lets see what gets to the top spot in our top 10 (list in descending order)
Number 10: Toulon Design Le Mans (2018)
Feel 9/10
Alignment 8/10
Forgiveness 8/10
Distance Control 6.5/10
Summary - The Toulon Design Le Mans is a premium mid-mallet putter crafted for golfers who value precision, feel, and aesthetics.
Number 9: Cleveland Frontline Elevado (2020)
Feel 7/10
Alignment 8/10
Forgiveness 9/10
Distance Control 8/10
Summary - The Frontline Elevado features forward weighting for stability and a better roll. The fang-style design ensures easy alignment, making it a great option for golfers who struggle with consistency.
Number 8: Ping Heppler Tyne 3 (2020)
Feel 8/10
Alignment 9/10
Forgiveness 8/10
Distance Control 8/10
Summary - The Ping Heppler Tyne 3 offers a striking design with adjustable weighting. Its solid face provides a firm feel, while the mallet head delivers forgiveness and alignment assistance.
Number 7: TaylorMade Spider X (2019)
Feel 8/10
Alignment 9/10
Forgiveness 9/10
Distance Control 8/10
Summary - The Spider X revolutionized mallet putters with its stability and sleek design. The True Path alignment system helps golfers frame the ball effectively, while the Pure Roll insert improves distance control.
Number 6: Odyssey Stroke Lab Ten (2019)
Feel 8.5/10
Alignment 8/10
Forgiveness 9/10
Distance Control 8/10
Summary - The Stroke Lab Ten is designed to improve stroke consistency with its innovative Stroke Lab shaft. Its high-MOI mallet head and Microhinge Star insert promote forgiveness and smooth roll.
Number 5: Scotty Cameron Select Newport 2 (2018)
Feel 10/10
Alignment 7/10
Forgiveness 6/10
Distance Control 9/10
Summary - The Select Newport 2 is the quintessential blade putter. While better suited for golfers with consistent putting strokes, its exceptional feel and precision make it a great tool for confident mid-handicappers.
Number 4: Evnroll ER2 (2017)
Feel 9/10
Alignment 8/10
Forgiveness 7/10
Distance Control 9.5/10
Summary - The Evnroll ER2 blade putter features groove technology designed to spread energy across the face, ensuring consistent distance even on mishits. Its compact shape suits golfers who favor traditional designs.
What makes our top three?
TaylorMade Spider GT (2022)
A futuristic mallet with high-MOI stability, bold alignment aids, and a soft Pure Roll² insert for unmatched control.
Scotty Cameron Futura 5S (2017)
A precision-engineered mallet offering forgiveness, premium feel, and confidence-inspiring alignment for every stroke.
These two incredible putters narrowly missed the top 10 but showcase top-tier performance and design. Want to know what made the top 3?
Keep reading to find out the absolute best putters for 2025!
Number 3: Cobra King 3D Printed Agera (2021)
Feel 8/10
Alignment 9/10
Forgiveness 10/10
Distance Control 8/10
Summary - The 3D Printed Agera combines 3D printed technology with incredible forgiveness. It's high-MOI design ensures stability, while its futuristic look appeals to golfers who want something bold.
Number 2: Odyssey White Hot OG #7 (2021)
Feel 8.5/10
Alignment 9/10
Forgiveness 9/10
Distance Control 9/10
Summary - The White Hot OG #7 takes Odyssey’s legendary insert technology and combines it with modern mallet design. It’s forgiving, easy to align, and delivers a smooth, consistent roll.
Number 1: TaylorMade Spider Tour (2018)
Feel 7/10
Alignment 9/10
Forgiveness 10/10
Distance Control 10/10
Summary - A proven performer trusted by professionals and amateurs alike. Featuring perimeter weighting and a Pure Roll insert, it’s forgiving, consistent, and deadly on the greens.
Our Summary
At Golfclubs4cash, we stock a wide range of pre-owned putters, thoroughly inspected and graded to ensure quality. Whether you’re after a modern mallet or a classic blade, we’ve got the perfect flat stick to upgrade your game.
It’s easy to buy top-quality, genuine and branded second hand golf clubs online when you shop with golfclubs4cash. We guarantee every purchase and offer worldwide delivery so you’ll have your new putter in your hand not long after hitting ‘buy’.
If you’ve narrowed it down to two or three options and you still can’t decide, give our friendly sales team a call. They’ll take you through a series of questions and advise on the perfect preloved golf club iron set for you. You may also find our FAQ section helpful.
More blogs and guides
Top Ten Putters To Buy Pre-Owned For 2025
A good putter can transform your game. Whether it’s draining clutch par saves or lagging those long ones close, finding the right...
Read more
Top Ten Irons To Buy Pre-Owned For 2025
Find out what the best irons for 2025 are that you can buy pre-owned to improve your game in this top picks...
Read more
PING’s Colour Coding System - What Is It?
Understanding the colour code system is essential when purchasing second-hand PING clubs, as the wrong fit can impact performance significantly.
Read more
Irons Comparison: Titleist 714 AP1 (2013) vs PING G25 (2013)
These two sets cater to very different styles of play, but both deliver outstanding performance in their own way.
Read more